Now Reading
Investment Strategies in Sports Cards Learned from Silver Stacking

Investment Strategies in Sports Cards Learned from Silver Stacking


As a sports card investor, have you ever thought of venturing into another investment realm? Do you have a previous background from a prior experience of investing? I personally came from buying and selling stocks then used the money that I got to invest in bitcoin. Then, from my profits in bitcoin, I invested in silver and gold. After the upswing of gold and silver, I then turned it into sports cards where I saw a huge potential. 

Silver stacking is a way people try to save up some money on the side and to grow their precious metals eventually. There are multiple ways in how one should get into it. I’m actually surprised that some people in the hobby of sports cards are actually doing or have done the route I did. Like sports cards, silver has different brands. It can range from buying the American Silver Eagle to Canadian Maple Leafs. On the other hand, sports cards have multiple brand variations like Topps, Panini, and Upper Deck.

What I want to share with you is how my silver investment strategy helped me make my own strategy in investing in sports cards. One can simply think, “well, just buy low and then sell high.” However, no one ever talks about building your inventory as a minimum wager. Well, stacking taught me how to and I was able to translate this into my venture into sports cards.

First, I looked at my salary. I was earning near the California minimum wage standard which was fifteen dollars an hour. In a month with forty hours of work, my salary before taxes is around $2400. One of the major rules in investing or saving is taking out ten percent of your salary to do it.  That means there is $240 ready to be spent every month that can be your savings or sports cards. In my case, I easily decided to use that money as both savings and sports cards. One half of it would be on my savings and the other will be that PSA 10 “insert the rookie of your choice here.” This way, you are both comfortably saving your future child’s college fund and able to sustain growth in your collection.

Second, premiums and market demand. In silver, there will always be a difference. There will always be a premium in buying and selling American Silver Eagles. But, some people would prefer rounds (generic brand) which has a lesser premium. Like silver, sports cards also have premiums which are licensing. When I was selling my silver I realize that the American Silver Eagles gave me a good return of investment but the entry price to get into it was high. You can say the same with sports cards as a Donruss rookie card of Shohei Ohtani will always be cheaper than the licensed Bowman Chrome rookie card of the same player. But take in mind, the rounds made me money as well. I was able to get a return but I was not able to maximize the return as it was a generic brand.  Now, there will always be the dilemma of every sports card investor which is the question of buying licensed or unlicensed products. I might be able to get a position on a player cheaper on an unlicensed product rather than a licensed product. Another precaution for unlicensed products is there will only be a limited market that I can sell to. But like silver, no matter what the brand is, there will always be the inherent value which is the player. Here’s a little comparison, PSA 10 Panini Donruss Optic Red /17 of Shohei Ohtani sold for $456. While a PSA 10 Topps High Tek Autograph /25 of Shohei Ohtani sold for $349. Donruss Optic is one of the flagship cards of Panini while Topps High Tek is (to be honest) just another set. Now, that made me think that unlicensed product isn’t as bad as you think. In precious metals, some people wouldn’t buy the round.

The reason is simply that, America will always recognize the silver eagle. Any pawn shop or coin shop will recognize that silver coin was minted by America. While the round, there will be doubts attached to it and targeted to a lesser market. Hence, MLB will always back the fact that Ohtani’s true licensed rookie cards were from Topps rather than Panini. Now going back to the comparison, High Tek isn’t one of the best sets by Topps in terms of popularity while Panini’s Donruss Optic is one of their popular sets. The most coveted rookie of Ohtani will be the Bowman Chrome. A recently sold BGS 9.5 Autograph 10 Bowman Chrome Orange Refractor (Batting) of Shohei Ohtani sold for $3,350. While a non-autograph and non-graded, 2018 Bowman Chrome (Batting) of Shohei Ohtani sold for $299. By typing into the sold listings of baseball cards, Topps reigns supreme in baseball. This is where premiums and market demand will always favor the licensed product.

Third, I diversify my precious metals. Like silver and gold, there will always be another sport to collect. I collect baseball, basketball, and football cards. But I only buy what is their most known rookie cards. In baseball, I only collect PSA 10 1st Bowman Chrome Autographs and Topps Chrome Update rookie cards. In basketball, I only collect their PSA 10 Prizm rookie cards. Lastly, in football, I only collect their PSA 10 contenders rookie ticket cards. Why? Like in precious metals, every country takes pride in its mint. In America, the most recognized silver coin will be the American Silver Eagles. On the other hand, the most recognized silver coin in Canada is the Silver Maple Leafs. But in sports cards, there are so many sets that they release and to be honest, it is overwhelming. I fell into the trap of buying different types of sets and it just gave my plans a setback. Focusing on the most data-backed sets will help you be diverse and invest in multiple sports and be able to grow your collection comfortably.

In the end, it’s crazy that sports cards are good investment vehicles or an unconventional savings account. But the most important lesson in precious metals is knowing that this is not a race but a marathon in accumulating wealth. Thank you for reading the article and I hope you learned something from my experience.

Do you use the skills learned in sports card investing in any other markets or visa versa? Leave your thoughts in the comments below!

Are you a new investor or collector? Make sure to join our Facebook Group and Discord Chat to continue learning and to meet other sports card investors.

View Comments (6)
  • This is one of the best sports card investment articles I’ve ever read. Great comparison between silver and sports cards! You are a very knowledgeable fellow in investing. You also prove that you don’t have to be rich to invest in anything!

  • The addition to his strategy and way to maximize is buy the ungraded Mint and send them to be graded but theirs markets to both so just as his coin reference and the branded and licensed. A benifit to this is it’s way cheaper hand have option to not grade and just case yourself and save more different players. A career can end instantly not just to injury either he has chances to lose lots of his guy he invested all that money in and instead if he bought ungraded mints hed have lots money to buy other players decreasing the chance or risk of loss. I have so much Value in my collection problem is parting with non dup’s or the work to sell. Unlike his silver and gold values a card is only worth what the interested person is willing to pay a guy like above just pull from a pack buy older cards pre 80 mints that’s better the already had the career.

  • This was a great article. I have collected sports cards since I was a kid. Something I did with my dad. A hobby that I did not participate in for over a decade and was pleasantly surprised with when I came back. Recently I have begun investing in silver and I do feel the similarities. Sports cards have mainly been a hobby for me but recently I have made some purchases as an investment. Something satisfying about holding your investment in your hands and I get that with both.

  • Sports cards are nothing like a traditional commodity. They fluctuate by multiples not percentages. I like the premise, but this guy doesn’t seem to have much knowledge of the players who’s performance drives the value. It is much more important to buy low and sell at the right time, than to invest and wait for years. Unless a player is an all time great, only Mike Trout is especially valuable in baseball, the value decreases after they descend from their prime. There are sales tax fees on purchases and then selling fees. That crushes 15% of your potential earnings off the top. Unless you follow the card markets and player performance on a weekly basis, this article will lose money. Using Ohtani as an example shows the lack of knowledge. One more arm injury and his value will drop by more than half. Buying the best cards is an easy way to lose a thousand dollars.

  • I find it all too confusing. Willing to admit the fact. I have 5000 ungraded cards. No Sentimental value here. Have a Jordan card. One site shows the Blue Backround Card $9.99 and another site… E-bay a seller puts $120,000.00 price, for HIS card. Because, in Grading it…the grading serial #’s on it now-
    236028. 23 – his jersey # 60-his White Sox #, 2= nothing & 8 – years he led scoring points. What That got to do with the price of Tea in China??? I want the most I can get for cards, no doubt. 68′ Bench Rookie, Namath, Montana, Brady, Thomas, Bo, Fukudome. But how does a seller want $9.99 for a same card as another ask $120K.! I don’t get it!!!

Leave a Reply

© 2021 Sports Card Investor, LLC. All rights reserved.

Investing in cards involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. READ OUR DISCLAIMER.